New York led by a score of 3-0 in the top of the eighth inning when Judge come up to bat. He hit what appeared to be a towering home run to left field, though the third base umpire ruled the ball foul. A review was ordered, but the call ultimately stood. Reporters asked Judge about the call during the postgame interview.

After the Yankees lost the replay challenge, Judge ending up being rung up on the next pitch, a 3-2 slider that nicked the outside corner at the bottom of the zone. Boone was ejected arguing the strikeout pitch with plate ump Adam Beck.